Home   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us
US Canada Europe Australia Singapore

   Products & Services
   About PIMCO
   Press Centre
   Bond Resources
   Career Information
   Content Archive

 

 

Viewpoints

September 2009
Return of the Old Ways of Thinking Threatens Recovery
Mohamed El-Erian
CEO and co-CIO
Download PDF
E-Mail Alerts
<< Archive

We are at the point of maximum confusion in the multi-year transition of the global economy, markets and policymaking. We have left the global growth regime that was driven primarily by debt-financed consumption in the US, but we have not as yet reached a position of more balanced, albeit anemic, growth. Those who lack a robust anchoring framework, be they investors or policymakers, risk being misled and backtracking to outdated ways of thinking.

The signs of inappropriate reversion are multiplying. Confusing temporary factors for sustainable ones, a growing number of analysts have extended the ongoing stimulus/inventory bounce to a V-like recovery next year and beyond. The momentum for meaningful financial reform is stalling in spite of clear evidence that financial activities have far outpaced the regulatory infrastructure. And some banks are returning to the bad habits that almost destroyed them.

This reversion is intimately linked to the inadequacy of the anchoring analytical frameworks. Appropriate frameworks provide important protection against the short-termism that can contaminate markets and policymaking. By contrast, ill-designed frameworks can encourage short-term thinking, leading to market and policy overshoot on the way up and down.

Today’s lack of appropriate anchoring frameworks appears to be exacerbating short-termism. The issue goes well beyond the still-limited appreciation of the multi-year realignment of the global economy, which is gaining momentum. It also relates to tendencies well-documented by behavioural economists – such as framing the problem wrongly and refusing to question past approaches.

Given all this, we would be all well advised to follow the admonition of Mervyn King. Last month, the governor of the Bank of England stated bluntly: “It’s the level, stupid – it’s not the growth rates, it’s the levels that matter here.” Investors have not yet accepted his insight that the absolute levels of income, debt, wealth and unemployment, not just the rates of change, are what matter today. They need to, and soon.

Analysis of key levels in the global economy points to important deviations between desired and actual levels. The outlook for major countries will continue to be driven by the levels of key variables, not their rate of recovery. Consider four examples.

First, consumer indebtedness is still too high relative to income expectations and credit availability, particularly in the US and the UK. This inconsistency will hold back any sustainable bounce in the most important component of aggregate demand.

Second, some banks’ balance sheets are still too geared for the comfort of regulators or their own managers. This will inhibit them from lending to the real economy at a time when certain sectors (such as commercial real estate, but also residential housing) still require significant refinancing, and when consumers need time to work down their excessive debt loads.

Third, unemployment has risen well beyond expectations, and is likely to prove unusually protracted. It will take years for US unemployment to return to its natural rate, even after the natural rate shifted upwards. This will dampen the recovery of consumption and investment, stress social contracts that assume flexible labour markets, and endanger political support for essential structural reforms.

Finally, public debt has grown so rapidly as to spark concerns about future debt dynamics. This would inhibit the effectiveness of future stimulus measures, as well as complicating the formulation of exit strategies. It could also erode the medium-term ability of the US to fund cheaply its large deficits by undermining both the global standing of the dollar as world reserve currency and the attractiveness of US financial markets.

These factors work against the much-needed handover from temporary growth impulses (which will bolster growth for the remainder of this year) to the permanent ones needed to sustain above-trend growth in 2010 and beyond. As such, the global economy may find it tough to attain Larry Summers’s “escape velocity” – sufficiently high and sustained growth to propel the US (and the rest of the world) away from the contractionary drag of further debt reduction, risk aversion and reregulation.

These considerations serve to accentuate the inconsistency between market valuations and the reality facing companies and economies. Today’s markets – be they industrial country equities or corporate bonds – have priced in vigorous growth for 2010. Valuations assume companies will be able robustly to grow earnings through higher revenues, not renewed reliance on the cost reductions that have propelled earnings in the past six months. For that, they are depending on what is likely to prove to be an elusive high-growth scenario for 2010.

The longer it takes for investors and the policy consensus to shift to the appropriate analytical framework – one that factors in levels rather than just rates of change – the greater the risk of disappointment in 2010. Mr. King’s insight will need to be more widely appreciated if the global economy is to avoid a growth and wealth relapse next year.

London
PIMCO Europe Ltd
(Registered in England and Wales, Company No. 2604517)
Registered Office
Nations House
103 Wigmore Street
London W1U 1QS
England
+44 (0) 20 7872 1300

Munich
PIMCO Europe Ltd Munich Branch
(Registered in Germany, Company No. 157591)
Registered Office
Seidlstraße 24-24a
80335 Munich
Germany
+49 (0) 89 1221 90

Amsterdam
PIMCO Europe Ltd Amsterdam Branch
(Registered in The Netherlands, Company No. 24319743)
Registered Office
Schiphol Boulevard 315
Tower A6
1118 BJ Luchthaven Schiphol
The Netherlands
+31 (0) 20 655 4710

PIMCO Europe Ltd, PIMCO Europe Ltd Munich Branch, and PIMCO Europe Ltd Amsterdam Branch are authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority in the UK, 25 The North Colonnade, Canary Wharf, London E14 5HS.  PIMCO Europe Ltd Munich Branch is additionally regulated by the BaFin in Germany in accordance with Section 53b of the German Banking Act and PIMCO Europe Ltd in Amsterdam is additionally regulated by the AFM in the Netherlands.  The services and products provided by PIMCO Europe Ltd are available only to professional clients as defined in the Financial Services Authority's Handbook. They are not available to individual investors, who should not rely on this communication.

This material contains the opinions of the author but not necessarily those of PIMCO and such opinions are subject to change without notice. This material has been distributed for informational purposes only and should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed. This material was reprinted with permission of Financial Times. Date of original publication 28 September 2009.



Products & Services   |   About PIMCO   |   Press Centre
Bond Resources   |   Career Information   |   Content Archive